Showing posts with label comments. Show all posts
Showing posts with label comments. Show all posts

A Commenting We Will Go


A little help.

Feel free to comment HERE, on this post, for the previous one. Let's see if that works.

Comments, censorship and editorial balance

Yesterday the IPKat reminded readers that this blog does not refuse to post comments with which he and Merpel disagree. Since then it has received a number of comments to contrary effect. One, for instance, reads:
"I have posted much comments in latest days such as information from enlarge appeal board and trying to get letter to administrating council. No comment is ever put in the blog. No one comment. Is strange I think because much comments are more critic".
This Kat repeats: we are perfectly willing to post comments that are relevant to the post on which they are commenting, regardless of the position they take, and so long as they are not abusive or obscene.  He does not think it strange when only one side is represented in readers' comments since it's quite a frequent occurrence -- but he agrees that, the larger the number of comments received on any given blogpost, the more unlikely it is that readers will be reflecting the same view.

Incidentally, the IPKat and Merpel don't actually reach a consensus position and then press for it: the team consists of some ten IP enthusiasts from different countries and with different backgrounds. Sometimes some members of the blog team consult with one another or see each other's posts before they go live, but this is not the rule.

Another anonymous commenter wrote as follows:
"I have commented many times on this blog. Most comments are posted, but I find comments that tend to be critical, directly or indirectly, of the original poster (not o the patently-o type) tend to go amiss. I know that sometimes my postings do not appear because I failed to prove I was not a robot and closed the box without realizing, others I guess may have seen lost somewhere else along the way, but since the ipkat censorship assertion several months ago, I am finding more posts going missing as described.

If posts do go amiss for technical reasons are the ipkat administrators aware of this problem, and how are we to judge whether the censorship line has been crossed?"
For obvious reasons the IPKat's authors (we all check for comments to moderate) cannot be aware of a problem of posts that go missing unless someone tells them, If you have tried to post a comment and it has not appeared on the blog, please email the IPKat at theipkat@gmail.com (using an anonymous or pseudonymous email source if you like) and let us have sight of the text in question. We will either post it or, in the unlikely event that it does not meet our criteria, we will respond and explain why.  This Kat will also raise the question with his fellow Kats as to whether we might ask a suitably non-bloggy person to act as an independent referee in the case of comments that are received but not posted.

The following links may also be of some assistance:
  • Diagnosing problems with Blogger comments here
  • Troubleshooting comments for Blogger here
FURTHER NOTE: since posting this item, it occurs to this blogger that comments are sometimes received as emails to individual members of the blog team, and sometimes to an unattended Gmail account that is used solely for the purposes of being able to log on to Blogger and compose blog posts. Also, some people try to respond to blog posts which they have received by email, clicking "reply" and responding to the Google Group which sends out the emails in the first place.  PLEASE: if you want to post a comment, can you seek to do so initially via the "Comment" link at the foot of the blog post upon which you seek to make a comment. 
Some users are seeing bX errors when attempting to leave comments on a blog with word verification enabled. We're investigating the issue and hope to have it resolved soon.
We're investigating reports of users not being able to comment on IE8/9 from the embedded form. We hope to have a fix out shortly, but in the meantime we encourage admins to switch to either the full-page or pop-up forms which should be working without issue.

Thanks for your patience, and we'll make sure to update this post as soon as we have more info.
We're investigating an issue which is preventing login and comment posting for some users, and hope to have a fix released shortly.

Thanks for your patience in the meantime.
Some users are reporting bX errors when attempting to post comments. Our team is investigating the issue and will follow-up here as soon as we have more information.

Update 5/1: This has been fixed, thanks for your patience.
The comment form on individual Pages is currently not rendering, returning a bX-duc6dq error code. We're working to resolve this as soon as possible.

Thanks for your patience in the meantime.
Some users are experiencing comment count discrepancies on their blog, specifically for older comments during the December-January timeframe. We have isolated the underlying problem though, and are working to release a fix shortly.

Also, if you have recently switched hosting from BlogSpot to a custom domain, it may take up to a few hours before the counts are synced completely (and this is expected).
Some users are reporting errors when attempting to moderate comments on their blog. We're investigating this issue and will update this post when we have more info to share.

Thanks for your patience.

2196247

Some profile images are failing to display on embedded comment forms with many comments. We're looking into this and will reply with and update shortly.
Thanks for your patience.

2137567

Some users are seeing a bX-lhziiw exception when attempting to moderate comments from the dashboard; we're investigating this right now and will report back with an update shortly. 

Thanks for your patience.

2019354

Some Safari users attempting to comment on blogs with the embedded form are seeing a "Your request could not be processed. Please try again" message as the comment fails to post. However, posting is usually successful if attempted the second time.

We're looking into this and apologize for the inconvenience.

1864879

Some users are having trouble deleting comments which contain certain special characters and/or certain HTML tags. We're looking into this issue and will update this post once we have a fix.

Thanks for your patience.
Today, we became aware of a bug affecting Blogger's comment feature. Within four hours of identifying the bug, we began to roll out a fix to all users affected. We take Blogger issues very seriously, and sincerely apologize for any inconvenience caused. The bug has been fixed; if you're still experiencing problems, please post details in our Help Forum.

Comments feed not updating 1562053

Comment feeds for some users are not updating properly, and may be missing recent comments in some cases.

We are looking into this now and hope to have it resolved shortly. Thanks for your patience.

200+ comment issue

Some users are having issues with displaying more than 200 comments for a particular post on their blog. We are aware of this issue and are working on a fix.
If you have a customized template or have inserted some 3rd party code into your template, your embedded comment form may not appear as normal.
Comment pagination does not work in post view on blogs with Classic templates. To workaround this issue, click through to the comments form.

Update, 2/29: Comment pagination on Classic templates is now available by adding the <$CommentPager$> tag to your template.

Update, 5/6: Comment pagination does not work for blogs published with FTP.

OpenID

Blogger has removed the URL field for unauthenticated comments. Instead, we're rolling out support for OpenID, a technology for "signing" your comments with your own URL. OpenID lets you comment with the URL you want, while preventing others from impersonating you. Blog admins can turn on OpenID now on Blogger in Draft. Learn more.

Comment of the week, 'Bongs Hit 4 Sahrawis' edition

In the grand tradition of the Comics Curmudgeon, I'm going to start highlighting a comment each week that particularly caught my eye.

In the future I'll be on the lookout for particularly well-reasoned argument on either side or Mohammed VI jokes. We'll kick it off, though, with a nod to inscrutability and narco-politics courtesy of an anonymous comment. Sic is implied.
let me give you a small advice if i may i think you should see your doctor (pronto) ,you may have what we call a moroccan syndrome luckily morocco does have a cure for such illness and the moroccans we'll be happy to help you (pronto)silly me i repeat the word pronto twice ,anyway this is what you need for your cure,you need to get your hands on couple of ounces of moroccan honey i think you know what i mean& you shouuuuld smoke couple of joint every night before your bedtime for 3 months and that my friend will do the trick , feel free to give my solution to your bodies,once you finish the cure you'll become in love with the moroccans
yous Moroccan formula
You laugh, but a smoke-up was part of the first Baker proposal.