Counting the cost of East Africa's poaching economy

Organised crime gangs in East Africa are generating staggering profits smuggling ivory and rhino horn with impunity, experts say, threatening both an irreplaceable wildlife heritage and key tourism industries.

A Kenya Wildlife Service (KWS) Ranger inspects and numbers a confiscated ivory
haul at Mombasa Port on October 8, 2013 [Credit: AFP/Ivan Lieman]

Kenyan and Tanzanian ports are the "primary gateway" for ivory smuggled to Asia, where demand is fuelled by increasingly affluent markets, especially in China, the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) warns.

Last year, seizures of ivory shipments reached "record levels", according to a recent Interpol report.

"Large-scale ivory shipments -- each one representing the slaughter of hundreds of elephants -- point to the involvement of organised crime networks operating across multiple countries," Interpol said.

Poaching has risen sharply across Africa in recent years.

Organised gangs with insider knowledge and armed with automatic weapons and specialised equipment such as night vision goggles, brazenly use chainsaws to carve out the rhino horn or remove elephant tusks.

Officers from Kenya Wildlife Services (KWS) attend to a sedated black Rhinoceros at Nairobi 
national park on November 7, 2013 during an excercise to implant microchips
in an effort to stem poaching [Credit: AFP]

Veteran Kenyan conservationist Richard Leakey has now warned that drastic action must be taken, saying that known ring-leaders in Kenya are operating with "outrageous impunity".

The rise in poaching, with animals being slaughtered inside even the most heavily guarded national parks or conservation areas, show that the poachers have little fear of tough new laws designed to stem the wave of killings, he said.

"They could not operate with the impunity we are seeing if you did not have some form of protection from law enforcement agencies," Leakey said, as he made an appeal for Kenyan President Uhuru Kenyatta to take action.

"It is a problem of a few criminals... the ringleaders are known," he added, claiming that a core group of around 20 to 30 people were organising the mass poaching but that none had faced justice.

Big money

It's a lucrative business: a kilo of ivory is worth some $850 (650 euros) in Asia, with UNODC suggesting ivory smuggled to Asia from Eastern Africa was worth over $31 million (23 million euros) in 2011.

Elephants roam Kenya's Amboseli game reserve on December 30, 2012
[Credit: AFP/Tony Karumba]

But such short-term and finite profits generated by the spate of killings are threatening the far more valuable tourism industry, which in Kenya and Tanzania is the second largest foreign exchange earner after agriculture.

"The African elephant is not currently deemed 'endangered' as a species, but its decimation in Eastern Africa could be devastating," UNODC's report read.

"In addition to the reduction in genetic diversity, its loss could seriously undermine local tourist revenues, a key source of foreign exchange for many of the countries of the region."

But the region's two large container ports -- Mombasa in Kenya and Dar es Salaam in Tanzania -- are also notorious trafficking hubs, funnelling more elephant tusks to Asia than all of central, southern and west African nations combined.

The two nations made up almost two-thirds of all large shipments of ivory seized across the entire continent from 2009-2011, according to the Elephant Trade Information System (ETIS), a tracking database run by wildlife trade monitoring network TRAFFIC.

Ivory bracelets and ornaments are displayed at shop in Beijing
on February 27, 2013 [Credit: AFP]

Seizures of containers crammed full of tusks -- often hidden under foul-smelling fish or dried chili peppers in a bid to confuse sniffer dogs or discourage detailed searches -- are regularly found.

Much of the ivory smuggled is destined for China, whose rapidly growing economy has encouraged those enjoying disposable income to splash out on an ivory trinket as a sign of financial success.

"Growing affluence in China, where possession of elephant ivory remains a status symbol, appears to have rendered China the world's leading destination for illicit ivory," the UNODC report added.

The smuggling of rhino horns is a bigger problem for Southern Africa, which has far more of the endangered animals. It is often done by air, due to the value of the horn and its smaller size.

But scores of East African rhinos are also being killed despite wildlife rangers often risking their lives to protect them.

Few convictions 

Action is being taken including far stiffer sentences for wildlife crime, with Tanzania this month jailing a Chinese ivory smuggler to 20 years in jail, and Kenya introducing tough new laws with comparable penalties.

Kenyan palaeontologist Richard Leakey gives a press conference on March 19, 2014 in Nairobi,
calling for an emergency response to elephant and rhino poaching
[Credit: AFP/Tony Karumba]

But many escape justice: a recent study by the Kenyan conservation campaign group Wildlife Direct found that just four percent of those convicted of wildlife crime in the past spent time in jail.

Tanzania last year launched a crackdown on suspected poachers, operating under what was reported to be a shoot-to-kill policy and making sweeping arrests.

Leakey, 69, a Kenyan national and former head of the government's Kenya Wildlife Service (KWS), said with the "right management" stemming the poaching was "not an impossible" task.

He was key in stemming the rampant poaching of the late 1980s, bringing in extreme measures to combat poachers including sending helicopter gunships into national parks, and organising the iconic burning of stockpiled ivory.

"It is not valuable, it is tragic rubbish," Leakey said, waving an ivory carving seized from a smuggler, the tiny tusk of a baby elephant.

"It is putting at risk our heritage... you can regrow a crop but you cannot regrow a wildlife species that disappears."

Author: Peter Martell | Source: AFP [March 23, 2014]