On the eve of International Women?s Day, so-called men?s rights advocates at the
University of Toronto hosted an event confronting women?s studies and academic feminism.
This was a follow-up to their event in November featuring self-proclaimed ex-feminist
Warren Farrell, author of the book the Myth of Male Power. Warren Farrell is best known
for his statements about women making false accusations of rape and his argument that
incest can be a positive experience, if only women were not socialized to be victims.
Though figures like this, who have written that, ?before we called this date rape and date
fraud, we called it exciting?, make it tempting to point to these inflammatory quotes to
justify our outrage at these groups, it is their fundamental discourse that we must
contend with.
Men?s Rights Associations have sprung up at universities across southern Ontario,
including Guelph, Waterloo, McMaster and multiple campuses in Toronto. Their main position
is that the hardships of men have been caused by women, the women?s rights movement and in
particular, feminists. They express this position with rhetoric ranging from downright
reasonable-sounding to blatantly misogynistic, but by only focusing on the latter, we risk
normalizing their fundamental message that feminism oppresses men. The exploitation and
increased incarceration or suicide rates of men have not been created by feminism. Some of
the supposed facts that they present, such as the prevalence of false rape accusations are
simply untrue, but those about drop-out rates, incarceration and suicide of men often
approximate truth. We do not need to negate these facts to contend with them, but instead,
must place them in an accurate political context, that of capitalism, patriarchy, and
white supremacy.
The emergence of these groups and the difficulties that we have faced organizing against
them are not, as these misogynists claim, a symptom of a feminist movement on campuses
gone-too-far, but a disturbing sign of the lack of radical feminist organizing in recent
years. As of late, students and leftists have most often responded to issues of patriarchy
through token lip service, and not organized responses. These misogynist organizations
have seized on this organizing vacuum, so that we are now in a position where the
historical fact of the systemic oppression of women is being challenged. As we began to
organize a response to this most recent event, we had to confront the criticisms leveraged
from our previous action ? doors were blocked, there was a confrontation with the police,
and vocal or militant women present at the demonstration were identified and targeted on
the internet, harassed and threatened.
As with populist white supremacist organizations, these misogynist groups have relied
heavily on arguments of free speech and the ?reverse oppression? faced by the white man at
the hands of organized marginalized groups. In some spaces, the debate was successfully
reframed to be about the illegitimacy of militancy and the virtues of free speech. We
should know to expect these arguments. With the administration siding with the
misogynists, many organizing around this issue along liberal lines were visibly shaken.
Many were afraid to confront the misogynists again, for fear of retaliation. Nevertheless,
what must be done remains the same. We need to move towards reactivating a radical,
militant feminist movement that can contend, not just with the backwards misogynists of
the men?s rights movement, but with the issues that continue to affect women everyday on
their campuses, from systemic oppression in male-dominated fields to the high prevalence
of sexual assaults, not by turning to the police or the University administration, but
through a militant organized resistance.
Source URL:
http://linchpin.ca/content/Anti-oppression/Towards-Militant-Feminist-Movement-Confronting-Men%E2%80%99s-Rights-Organi
Links:
[1] http://linchpin.ca/vocab/marchTOphotojpg
==================================================
* Published on Linchpin - website of Ontario anarchist organization Common Cause
(http://linchpin.ca)
Home »
» Linchpin, Canada, Towards a Militant Feminist Movement: Confronting Men?s Rights Organizing*