A Tale of Two Pineapples

The grapefruit turns out to be sitting in a rather moldy basket. The pineapple by contrast grows in a grove of pineapple trees. So it's the pineapple.

But another pineapple had shown up. It's larger but less juicy than pineapple 1.

Which pineapple in the grove should it be? 1 or 2?